Famous Nyc Cheap Car Insurance References. Web our analysis found that the average cost of car insurance in new york is $1,808 per year. New york central mutual fire (nycm) and usaa are the cheapest new york car insurance companies for good drivers, among the companies.

Web our analysis found that the average cost of car insurance in new york is $1,808 per year. Cheapest car insurance in new york for full coverage Geico, erie and state farm also.